Having three children, now (thankfully) all out of diapers, I've researched and written on the subject. One thing I was surprised to learn was that children today are potty-training much later than they were 50 and even 100 years ago. With technology, the internet and the advances in medicine and science, it's almost hard to comprehend that potty-training has actually regressed. We're so used to faster-better-new-and-improved-at-your-fingertips-millisecond EVERYTHING ALL THE TIME in 2015, that it's completely contrary to all of the progress we've made in other areas. Why is this? I did some more research and a little brainstorming. After a quick Google search, I found and enjoyed reading: A History of Potty Training. The invention of disposable diapers has actually negatively impacted how quickly children potty train—if you are using age as a measure. According to PottyTrainingConcepts.com:
- In the 1950s, almost a 100% of children wore cloth diapers and 95% of these children were trained by the age of 18 months.
- In the 1980s, about 50% of children wore cloth diapers, while the other 50% wore disposable diapers and only about 50% of the children were potty trained by the age of 18 months.
- Today, almost 90-95% of children wear disposable diapers and only about 10% of children are potty trained by the age of 18 months.
- Today, the average age for potty training is about 30 months with the age ranging from 18-60 months.
I had always heard that cloth diapers = earlier potty training, but that was not the case for us. My daughter was stubborn and actually told me she liked pooping in her diaper vs the potty. (Trust me, I tried everything to get her to go on the potty. It lead to her holding it in, which created an entirely new set of problems.) Not sure if we’ll do anything different with #2, but I’m sure each child is different and there is no “normal”!
No matter how much I tried, my first 3 children were right at 3 before “getting” it. Now with #4, he’s 26 months, and we just started trying, but because I’m nursing a newborn, I’m not getting up to make/take him potty, and he’s not willing to go when I do urge him to sit. he likes the big potty, not the little potty chair, and treats aren’t incentive enough yet…we’ll see how well this works, but it may take a while. I’m a stay at home mom, but still, if the child isn’t ready, how do you “make” him go???
I never knew that children who cloth diapered potty train earlier. Definitely another advantage!
Potty training my daughter took forever. She sat on the potty for 10 to twenty minutes every hour with no results, only to have her go in the pull up shortly after putting it on. I finally had to switch to cloth training pants and she eventually got it. She did still have accidents in those as well. My son has been in cloth since 10 months old so hopefully he will be easier.
Interesting article. My first thought was my own laziness. I did, of course, want my child to be potty trained and successful, but out of convenience, timing, ect, we were not able to spend a lot of time working with her until recently. She had a trainer potty since she was 1, but is now 32 months and fully trained after working really hard together over spring break. We decided to not even bother with putting pull ups on in public, because I knew I would be tempted to not listen to her if her need to pee was bad timing. We used disposable with her and she was probably mostly ready to train around 18 months, went rebellious for a period of time, and then was old enough to change her own clothes and wanted “princess panties” instead of her diapers. I am curious to see how things will go with me staying at home and with my other two.
You're viewing 11-15 of 44 comments